Cheryl’s Pizza

Stepping into Cheryl’s Pizza feels like settling into a familiar neighborhood retreat tucked along Waterville’s lively Water Street. The rhythm here is casual and unhurried—an inviting space where friendly faces and the scent of fresh-baked pizza mingle effortlessly, striking a balance between low-key comfort and approachable warmth.

This is the kind of spot where the hum of laughter and easy conversation seems to weave through the air, echoing the genuine care found behind the counter. Whether you’re dropping by for a quick slice or gathering with friends and family over a more relaxed meal, the atmosphere embraces you with an easygoing charm that never feels rushed.

Cheryl’s menu complements this vibe perfectly. There’s a satisfying heartiness to the food—crispy, golden fries share the stage with hand-tossed pizzas topped with pepperoni or something a little more adventurous like the steak bomb. The wings and smash burger echo that same comforting, made-for-sharing feeling, each bite inviting a moment savored rather than hurried. Among the tastes here, even classic sides earn their place, with onion rings and slaw that add a thoughtful, homemade touch.

Patrons often find themselves drawn not just by the food but by the genuine warmth of the service—friendly smiles, quick takeout that feels seamless, and a staff that remembers names and favorites. It’s a small place where those thoughtful moments quietly elevate the everyday meal into something a little more memorable. For locals and visitors alike, Cheryl’s Pizza offers more than just a bite to eat; it’s a gentle reminder of why neighborhood spots hold a special place in our lives.